Wet paddocks and drainage on Auckland clay soils
Every winter the same paddock goes the same way. The gateway turns to soup, water lies in the dip by the fence, and by August the grass has given way to a patchwork of hoof holes. Clay soils drain slowly, and Auckland has plenty of them. The fix is partly engineering and partly habit, and it begins with understanding what is going on under your boots.
Why clay holds water
Auckland Council's soil information inventories give a feel for the problem. The inventory covering Waitākere and related soils, which sit extensively through the central and western parts of the Waitākere Ranges, describes Waitākere clay as lying under ridges and easy upper slopes. Its estimates for that soil put a slowly permeable layer at about 0.6 to 1.19 metres down, with permeability through that layer below 4 millimetres an hour. The same council inventory says these soils are not versatile, limited partly by leaching and wetness at elevation. It also warns that its soil estimates are compiled from older sources, so treat the numbers as a guide to the type of soil rather than a measurement of your own paddock.
The principle holds well beyond the Waitākere foothills. When a layer under the topsoil lets water through only very slowly, rain fills the topsoil from the bottom up and the paddock sits saturated. Dig a test hole after heavy rain and see whether water collects in it. That tells you more than a soil map.
What pugging does
Waikato Regional Council explains pugging and compaction clearly. When stock trample wet soil, the soil aggregates break down and the pore spaces shrink. That is pugging. The result is poorer drainage, since the soil stays softer and wetter and is therefore more prone to further pugging, along with lower pasture yield, higher fertiliser needs and more topsoil running off to waterways. Compaction by machinery has similar effects. Clay soils are called out as being at higher risk.
So wet paddocks make themselves wetter. Beating that cycle means keeping stock and tyres off soft ground as well as moving water.
Drainage options
Northland Regional Council's soil and pasture management guidance is written for dairy farms but its drainage section applies to a lifestyle block on similar clay. Its key points:
- Good drainage means paddocks stay wet for the shortest possible time after heavy rain. It reduces treading damage but does not eliminate it. Even well-drained paddocks will pug in heavy rain.
- Talk to local consultants and farmers about what suits your soil and contour.
- Where flat land is wet because of runoff from springs or hills above it, open or pipe drains that intercept the runoff can solve the problem at its source. Open drains should be fenced from stock to protect water quality and cut maintenance.
- Not every area needs draining, and drainage is not always cost-effective once you count maintenance. Springs, seeps and swampy gullies, when fenced, filter runoff, reduce flood flows and reduce nitrogen in water before it reaches streams.
- On flat land with a high winter water table, mole drains are an option. They last longer in soils with a clay content greater than 20 percent, when pulled in late spring or summer with soil temperature above 12 degrees, soil moist but drying, and pasture short. The guide's test is to roll soil into a worm about 3 mm thick and 50 mm long: if you can just form it, conditions suit moling. Mole drains need good outlets, and they fail faster if the surface is pugged. Where moles connect to a pipe system, put the pipes in first.
- Subsurface drainage can carry polluted water from paddocks straight to the discharge point, bypassing the filtering of stream-side planting, so manage grazing carefully on drained soils when they are wet.
The guide's top tips also include grading paddocks by how susceptible they are, using on-off grazing or wintering off, spelling pugged pastures, and considering drainage or retirement for chronically wet sites.
Grazing habits that cost nothing
Waikato Regional Council's list of ways to limit damage reads well on a small block:
- Graze the wetter paddocks before the wet part of the season, and build pasture cover going into it, since good cover protects against pugging.
- Graze at-risk land with lighter stock.
- Use the farm bike rather than a heavy tractor.
- Avoid working the soil when wet, and vary cultivation depth each year to avoid forming a plough pan.
Beyond pasture, there is the welfare side. MPI's code of welfare for sheep and beef cattle recommends that animals always have access to areas free of surface water and excessive mud, especially where small areas turn muddy in wet weather. A small, firm, well-drained stand-off area for stock to retreat to in winter does that job and takes pressure off the rest of the paddock.
If compaction has already set in, Northland's guidance says subsoiling works only when the soil is moist and friable, ideally in spring or autumn. If the soil is too wet the subsoiler does not lift and crack it and instead creates more compaction. Mole ploughing may be a better option than subsoiling in heavy wet soils, because the mole channel carries water off the paddock.
Before you dig anything
Drainage can affect more than your paddock. The Ministry for the Environment's wetlands factsheet explains that national freshwater rules, in force since September 2020, place restrictions on damaging activities in and near natural wetlands. A seep, a rush-filled depression or a swampy gully might be one. That factsheet dates from 2020 and rules and definitions can change, so check the current position with Auckland Council before you drain, dig out or fill anything that holds water year-round, or that connects to a stream. Councils can also have earthworks rules, and a new drain that discharges on to a neighbour's land creates its own problems.
A sensible order of work is to fence off the wettest spots, fix the grazing pattern, and only then consider drains, starting with an intercept drain above the problem and professional advice on layout and outlets.
Sources
- Auckland Council: Soil information inventory 25, Waitākere, Huia and related soils
- Waikato Regional Council: Pugging and compaction
- Northland Regional Council: Soil and pasture management (chapter 2)
- Ministry for the Environment: Essential Freshwater wetlands factsheet
- MPI: Code of Welfare: Sheep and Beef Cattle